Suffolk County
Islip
131 closed sales · last 12 months
Updated monthly from closed-sale data.
Islip is a city in Suffolk County. The median sale price is $640,000, with homes selling at $421.96 per square foot. Annual sales volume runs about 132 transactions, and homes typically spend 50.5 days on the market before sale.
Over the last 12 months, Islip has outperformed Suffolk County, the county it sits within.
Islip market report, November 2026
Median Price
$645K
Half of sales closed above this price, half below.
Price / SF
$419/SF
Median closed price per square foot.
Closed Sales
131
Number of closed sales in the period.
Active Listings
44
Homes listed here right now.
Other 22 · House/Townhome 14 · Co-op 4 · Rental 4
Price Trend
Last 12 monthsClosed Sales
Livability
Tortus Score
Tortus Score rates walkability, transit, and nearby amenities across 5,598 locations in Islip. Higher is better.
Islip on the map
Notable nearby
Restaurants
- Koikokoro / Islip Ny0.2 mi
- Maxwell's0.2 mi
- Bubbas Burrito Bar0.2 mi
Coffee
- Starbucks0.2 mi
- Tim Hortons0.6 mi
Bookstores
- Islip Public Library0.3 mi
Nightlife & culture
- Long Island Photo Gallery0.2 mi
- Altamira0.2 mi
- Lily Flanagan's0.2 mi
Shopping
- Nook and Cranny0.2 mi
- SUBWAY0.2 mi
- Islip True Value Hardware0.2 mi
Getting around
Nearest stop: Montauk Hwy/Smith Ave · 4 min walk
Schools nearby
- Islip High SchoolHigh · 6 min walk
- Islip Middle SchoolMiddle · 9 min walk
- Wing Elementary SchoolElementary · 14 min walk
- Maud S Sherwood Elementary SchoolElementary · 18 min walk
- Commack Road Elementary SchoolElementary · 19 min walk
- Bay Shore Prekindergarten CenterElementary · 22 min walk
Key details
The cost of homes
The median sale price in Islip CDP is $635,000, roughly $55,000 lower than Suffolk County's median of $690,000. Homes typically sell between $432,500 and $750,000.
Housing stock
Properties in Islip CDP sell at $422.95 per square foot and typically spend 49.6 days on the market. The area recorded 131 sales over the past 12 months and is outperforming Suffolk County overall during that period.
Nearby neighborhoods
All figures reflect sales only; rentals are excluded.
Thinking about a move in this neighborhood?
Get a personalized valuation or talk through the market with a local expert.

