Manhattan
Turtle Bay
321 closed sales · last 12 months
Updated monthly from closed-sale data.
Turtle Bay is a sub-neighborhood within Midtown East. The median sale price is $890,000, with a price per square foot of $1,276.07. Annual sales volume runs to 327 transactions.
Over the last 12 months, Turtle Bay has trailed Midtown East, the neighborhood it sits within.
Turtle Bay market report, November 2026
Median Price
$890K
Half of sales closed above this price, half below.
Price / SF
$1,275/SF
Median closed price per square foot.
Closed Sales
321
Number of closed sales in the period.
Active Listings
228
Homes listed here right now.
Condo 134 · Co-op 86 · Condop 3 · House/Townhome 3 · Rental 2
Price Trend
Last 12 monthsClosed Sales
Who lives here
- 49,325
- Residents
- $159K
- Median household income
- $3K/mo
- Median rent
Source: U.S. Census (ACS), 2023 · Turtle Bay (2 ZIP codes)
Livability
Tortus Score
Tortus Score rates walkability, transit, and nearby amenities across 628 locations in Turtle Bay. Higher is better.
Turtle Bay on the map
Notable nearby
Restaurants
- Nino's Positano164 ft
- Angeletto232 ft
- Zara Terrace238 ft
Coffee
- Dag's Patio Cafe438 ft
- Remi Flower & Coffee465 ft
- Pennylane Coffee502 ft
Bookstores
- American India Foundation517 ft
- Hayle Medical0.1 mi
- Economic and Social Affairs Library0.2 mi
Nightlife & culture
- The Belleweather364 ft
- Dai Ichi Arts401 ft
- Fukusuke0.1 mi
Shopping
- Ekavi Boutique Inc211 ft
- Diplomatic Duty Free Shops of New York248 ft
- Columbia Cleaners259 ft
Getting around
Nearest stop: 2 AV/E 46 ST · 1 min walk
Getting to work
- 11 min
- Grand Central
- 14 min
- Columbus Circle
- 15 min
- Union Sq
- 26 min
- Financial District
- 32 min
- Downtown Brooklyn
By subway from Lexington Av/53 St (6 min walk) · typical scheduled MTA times.
Schools nearby
- PS 59 Beekman Hill InternationalElementary · 10 min walk
- Art and Design High SchoolHigh · 10 min walk
- River School (The)Elementary · 12 min walk
- PS 116 Mary Lindley MurrayElementary · 14 min walk
- Murray Hill AcademyHigh · 14 min walk
- Manhattan Academy for Arts and LanguagesHigh · 14 min walk
Key details
The cost of homes
The median sale price in Turtle Bay is $890,000, matching the median for Midtown East overall. Homes typically sell between $575,000 and $1,598,574.
Housing stock
Properties in Turtle Bay are selling at $1,276 per square foot and typically spend 191 days on market. The neighborhood recorded 327 sales over the past 12 months and is underperforming relative to Midtown East overall during the same period.
Nearby neighborhoods
All figures reflect sales only; rentals are excluded.
Thinking about a move in this neighborhood?
Get a personalized valuation or talk through the market with a local expert.

